Skip to content
AI Cyber Compare

Decision guide · Vendor facts read September 2026, updated 2026-10-13

AI SOC analyst, SOAR, MDR or SIEM copilot: which model fits your SOC team?

The short answer

Pick the model by who will do the work, not by the product. If your analysts are drowning in alerts they cannot read, an AI SOC analyst platform takes the first pass on every alert. If your responses are fixed and audited, SOAR still fits. If you have no one on shift at night, MDR buys people. If your team keeps up and wants to move faster inside its SIEM, a copilot is enough.

Who carries the alert queue in each model?

AI SOC analyst

AI SOC analyst platform

Software agents that triage and investigate alerts the way an analyst would, and in some products take response actions within limits you set.

Work strip for AI SOC analyst: Triage, AI agent; Investigate, AI agent; Respond, shared; Tune, shared; Nights and weekends, AI agent.TriageAI agentInvestigateAI agentRespondSharedTuneSharedNights and weekendsAI agent
Read about AI SOC analyst
SOAR

SOAR playbook engine

Security orchestration, automation and response: a workflow engine that runs playbooks your team writes in advance, across many integrated tools.

Work strip for SOAR: Triage, rules you write; Investigate, shared; Respond, rules you write; Tune, your analysts; Nights and weekends, rules you write.TriageRules you writeInvestigateSharedRespondRules you writeTuneYour analystsNights and weekendsRules you write
Read about SOAR
MDR

Managed detection and response (MDR)

A service in which a provider's analysts monitor your alerts, investigate them and respond or advise, usually around the clock.

Work strip for MDR: Triage, provider's analysts; Investigate, provider's analysts; Respond, shared; Tune, provider's analysts; Nights and weekends, provider's analysts.TriageProvider's analystsInvestigateProvider's analystsRespondSharedTuneProvider's analystsNights and weekendsProvider's analysts
Read about MDR
SIEM copilot

SIEM copilot

An AI assistant inside a SIEM or security console that answers questions in plain language, summarizes incidents and drafts queries when an analyst asks.

Work strip for SIEM copilot: Triage, your analysts; Investigate, shared; Respond, your analysts; Tune, shared; Nights and weekends, your analysts.TriageYour analystsInvestigateSharedRespondYour analystsTuneSharedNights and weekendsYour analysts
Read about SIEM copilot
  • Your analysts
  • Rules you write
  • AI agent
  • Provider's analysts
  • Shared
  • Not described

Our reading of who carries each stage by default. For a product it reflects what the vendor's public pages describe, not how your deployment will be set up.

Which questions decide the model?

  1. 01

    How many people work your alert queue today?

    With no analysts, software alone leaves nobody to own decisions; with a large team, writing playbooks is affordable.

  2. 02

    How does your alert volume feel?

    Unread alerts point to software that reads every alert; a manageable queue points to speed per alert.

  3. 03

    What do you run today?

    Many working playbooks are an asset; a SIEM with no SOAR leaves room to start agent-first.

  4. 04

    How far should software act on its own?

    The more you let software act alone, the more the model's guardrails matter.

  5. 05

    Who should do the work?

    Outsourcing buys people and hours; in-house keeps the knowledge.

Answer them in the fit finder

Which vendors did we profile?

Mate Security featured first, the rest alphabetical. No vendor is ranked on this site. Facts from vendor pages read in September 2026 and updated on 13 October 2026.
VendorModelPosition on SOARIntegrations publishedPricing published
Mate Security
AI SOC analyst
Replaces SOARNot publishedNot published
7AI
AI SOC analystMDR
Works beside SOARNot publishedNot published
Artemis Security
AI SOC analystSOARMDR
Replaces SOAR240+ connectors (Artemis states), including Splunk, Splunk SOAR, Microsoft Sentinel, CrowdStrike NG-SIEM, Snowflake, AWS Athena, BigQuery, Entra ID, Okta, CrowdStrike, SentinelOne and Defender XDR.Not published
Conifers CognitiveSOC
AI SOC analyst
Replaces SOAR90+ (homepage). A May 2026 release said 60+.Not published
Cortex XSOAR
SOARAI SOC analyst
Adds AI inside SOAR900+ prebuilt integrations and automation packs; thousands of security actions in the Marketplace.Not published
Dropzone AI
AI SOC analyst
Works beside SOAR90+ across 14 categories, including SOAR tools (Cortex XSOAR, Splunk SOAR, Tines, Torq, D3 Security, IBM QRadar SOAR, Swimlane).Tiers or unit published
Exaforce
AI SOC analystMDR
Replaces SOAR130+ across IaaS, SaaS, identity, endpoint, SIEM, SOAR, email, ticketing, threat intel and AI.Not published
Intezer
AI SOC analyst
Works beside SOAR100+Tiers or unit published
Prophet Security
AI SOC analystMDR
Replaces SOAR200+ out of the box.Not published
Splunk SOAR
SOARSIEM copilot
Adds AI inside SOAR300+ third-party tools and 2,800+ automated actions.Not published
Tines
SOARAI SOC analyst
Replaces SOARNot publishedTiers or unit published
Torq AI SOC Platform
AI SOC analystSOAR
Replaces SOAR300 pre-built integrations and 4,000+ pre-built steps, plus AI-generated integrations.Not published
Vega
AI SOC analystSIEM copilot
Works beside SOARNot publishedNot published

All facts in one table

What about MDR providers and SIEM copilots?

Five MDR providers and three SIEM copilots now have lighter profiles, built from their own pages read in October 2026. They sit under their models rather than in the fact table, because the 11 capabilities we track were defined for AI SOC and SOAR products. Profiled vendors that reach into those models are listed below.

  • 7AI: PLAID ELITE is a service in which 7AI experts run the platform 24x7, which puts it close to the MDR model.
  • Artemis Security: Artemis includes an AI-native SOAR builder aimed at teams maintaining a SOAR, and offers an MDR option in which its senior analysts operate the platform 24/7.
  • Exaforce: Exaforce can also run the platform for you, with its analysts and Exabots working 24/7, which puts that option in the MDR model.
  • Prophet Security: Prophet AI Watchtower is a 24x7x365 human-in-the-loop expert service, which brings the provider's analysts into the loop as in the MDR model.
  • Splunk SOAR: Splunk says SOAR is now a native capability of Splunk Enterprise Security, its SIEM, which it describes as integrated with agentic AI. The AI sits on the SIEM side, closest to the copilot model in our source set.
  • Vega: Vega positions itself for the post-SIEM era and recommends next actions for analysts to carry out rather than executing them, which puts it near the SIEM copilot model. It does not mention SOAR; any SOAR you run keeps response.

Lighter profiles

  • Arctic Wolf Aurora MDR: Arctic Wolf's managed detection and response, with 24x7 monitoring, response actions and a named Concierge team for every customer.
  • CrowdStrike Falcon Complete: CrowdStrike's 24/7 managed detection and response service, which it calls agentic MDR.
  • Daylight Security: An AI-native managed service in which AI agents and Daylight's senior experts run detection, investigation and response 24/7.
  • Expel MDR: Expel's managed detection and response, sold in three packages that all include 24x7 Expel SOC monitoring and access to Expel Workbench.
  • Zscaler MDR (formerly Red Canary): Red Canary's MDR, now sold as Zscaler Managed Detection and Response: 24/7 human-led, AI-powered support across identity, endpoint, cloud, email and network.
  • CrowdStrike Charlotte AI: CrowdStrike's AI for the SOC, which it describes as agentic: it "reasons, decides, and acts at machine speed" across domains.
  • Google Security Operations with Gemini: Google's security operations platform, unifying SIEM, SOAR and threat intelligence, with Gemini for natural-language search, investigation chat, case summaries and response recommendations.
  • Microsoft Security Copilot: Microsoft's generative AI assistant for security, available as a standalone experience or embedded in Microsoft Security products, priced in security compute units (SCUs).

What does this site claim, and what not?

We describe what vendors publish and organize it around the choice of model. We do not score or rank vendors, we did not run the products, and every vendor figure is quoted with its source and labelled as the vendor's own.

How we profile

What is new from The Triage Desk?

All dispatches

Asked often about this page

What is the difference between an AI SOC analyst and SOAR?

SOAR runs playbooks that people write in advance, so it handles the cases someone predicted. An AI SOC analyst platform investigates each alert at run time and reaches a verdict with evidence, so it reaches the long tail that playbooks miss. Several products now mix both.

Is MDR better than an AI SOC platform?

Neither is better in general. MDR buys analysts and hours from a provider; an AI SOC platform is software your own team runs. Teams with no one on shift at night often need the people; teams with analysts who want to keep knowledge in-house often prefer the software.

Is a SIEM copilot the same as an AI SOC analyst?

No. A copilot answers when an analyst asks. An AI SOC analyst platform picks up alerts from the queue and works them without being asked. The difference shows at night and in a backlog.

Which model does the fit finder recommend most often?

None by design. The finder adds published points for each answer and shows all four models in the order your answers produce, with the reasons. The point table is on How we profile.